The great volatility debate
Timothy McCourt and Matthew Tagliani, executive directors, equity products, CME Group
Despite a recent flurry of activity in
certain asset classes, volatility has not returned to financial markets in any
meaningful way and may not return so long as global central banks continue to
provide markets with excess liquidity and remain fully committed to providing
substantial assistance should any financial institution get into trouble. The
resilience of the market to the normal sources of volatility is demonstrated by
the contrast between the significance of recent geopolitical events with the
insignificance of the market’s reaction to them. In 2014, we have witnessed the
Russian annexation of Crimea, the shooting down of a civilian passenger plane
over Ukraine, aggressive economic sanctions against Russia by both the US and
EU, fresh instability in Iraq prompting new deployment of US troops and the
most violent conflict in Gaza in a decade.
And how have markets reacted? Equity markets are modestly higher, crude oil
remains flat, 10y US Treasury yields are down slightly and gold has
rallied. Both realized and
forward-looking implied volatility, after hitting decade lows in early summer,
have ticked up only slightly and remain very low by any historic measure.
Global financial markets are interconnected
and while central banks continue to intervene in two of the largest asset
classes – interest rates and currencies – there is little likelihood for the
return of significant volatility to any asset class in the near term. The next foreseeable catalyst will be when
(and if) major central banks such as the Federal Reserve or the Bank of
England, step back from their emergency policies of near-zero short-term
rates. As economic growth prospects
diverge between the US and UK on the one hand, and continental Europe and Japan
on the other, the likelihood of a meaningful rise in volatility increases.
Russell
Rhodes, senior instructor, CBOE Options Institute
It’s been well publicized that this year
the level of the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX), the most-cited measure of
expected volatility, has been low relative to levels in the post-2008 financial
crisis. As of early August, the average VIX closing price was 13.65, the lowest
average since 2005 when the close averaged 12.81. It would be incorrect, however, to assume
that VIX’s recent low level automatically equates to low market volatility
across the board, as there have been pockets of volatility in market sectors
that have experienced higher implied volatility in 2014 than in 2013.
The measure of volatility for small-cap
stocks in the US, represented by the CBOE Russell 2000 Index (RUT) – is one
area in which there have been excessive volatility levels relative to history. The
Brazilian market is another index displaying increased volatility expectations
in 2014. However until the national elections
pass, it is likely that volatility as indicated by option pricing will remain
elevated for the Brazilian market.
Finally, it is worth mentioning that
implied volatility is a mean-reverting measure, and VIX levels have been lower
than the long-term average for well over a year. In time, VIX undoubtedly will revert to a
higher level for several possible reasons. Some market watchers think we are
overdue for a market correction, others view the September-October period that
is almost upon us as being historically treacherous, while others believe that
we could experience another geopolitical flare up - one that lasts more than
two days. The question is not if
something will happen that pushes VIX higher, but when will it happen.
Vicky
Sanders, Head of Analytics Sales, Marex Spectron
“Double, double toil and trouble; fire burn
and caldron bubble.” We find ourselves not in a cave but four years into a volatility
bear market and while it won’t be eye of newt or toe of frog, there must be
something to stir some drama in the derivatives market. For volatility to rise,
either expectations of future price movements must change or demand for it must
increase. The question is obviously what can cause either to happen?
The reasons for the post-crisis collapse in
implied volatility curves are known to most: zero interest rates, range bound
markets, reduced risk appetites, fewer macro-economic surprises, and exhausted
demand for tail risk structures. The average one year realised volatility for a
group of ten benchmark commodities peaked at the 95th percentile at
the end of 2009. It has fallen steadily since, currently hovering just above
the 15th percentile. That is well below where we entered the
financial crisis when volatility sat nicely at the 50th percentile.
In markets that range, flat price positions
are eschewed in favour of spread and relative value trades. At the same time,
with lower volatility, VAR-driven position limits mathematically rise. Lulled into
a sense of calm, sizes of positions slowly expand while perceived risk falls,
creating a set up for a rather painful unwind. The brutal collapse of the
August-September Brent spread is a prime, and recent, example.
As ever in financial markets, timing is
key. So why now? In this cycle we have never been closer to a change in monetary policy. Positions have grown and prices have begun to move – various
commodities have broken out of ranges after events such as the Indonesian ore
ban, Artic vortex, and Brazilian drought. Brent & WTI flat prices have
broken lower on the multiple bubbling geopolitical risk areas – Gaza, Ukraine
and Iraq. Volatility in other asset classes has begun to rally. GBP/USD 1month
implied volatility is having the largest summer rally since 2008. As currencies
are directly linked to interest rate expectations, they may likely be the first
to move in a broader cross-asset resurgence in volatility.
Owain
Johnson, chief of products and services, Dubai Mercantile Exchange
This summer saw the Middle East and Asian
crude oil markets awaken to renewed volatility after an unusually extended
period of price stability was brought to a dramatic end by geopolitical
concerns in Iraq and Russia. After a first half characterized by price
stability and a lack of general trends to follow, the summer months have seen a
return to the volatility that had been the hallmark of the crude oil markets in
recent years.
The major driver of regional volatility was
and continues to be the uncertain situation in Iraq. The initial campaign by Iraqi insurgents in
mid-June pushed DME’s Oman crude oil futures contract to trade above $110bn for
the first time since the previous September.
The lower price levels came amid greater
confidence that Iraqi insurgents were not targeting the key southern oil-fields
and followed a reduced demand forecast from the International Energy Agency,
which cited weaker-than-expected second-quarter economic growth in developed
countries and a drop in oil stockpiling in China.
The regional oil markets continue to feel
very tense – weak refining margins and a surplus of crude would normally lead
to lower prices, but relatively few market participants feel comfortable in
taking a large short position when geopolitical risk surrounding two major
producers like Iraq and Russia remains so high.
The key question now is whether this summer
saw the return of a new period of greater volatility. Much will depend on how events in Iraq
unfold. The difficult situation there
has caused much work on new oil fields to cease, thereby reducing Iraq’s
medium-term production prospects. This
lack of increased supply from Iraq could well generate greater price movement
in the future as demand increases once more.
As well as generating short-term volatility, the impact of the situation
in Iraq is likely to be felt in the market for years to come.
Found this useful?
Take a complimentary trial of the FOW Marketing Intelligence Platform – the comprehensive source of news and analysis across the buy- and sell- side.
Gain access to:
- A single source of in-depth news, insight and analysis across Asset Management, Securities Finance, Custody, Fund Services and Derivatives
- Our interactive database, optimized to enable you to summarise data and build graphs outlining market activity
- Exclusive whitepapers, supplements and industry analysis curated and published by Futures & Options World
- Breaking news, daily and weekly alerts on the markets most relevant to you